Eat more weigh less
Three young women scurry back and forth from the stainless steel counters to the big walk-in refrigerator, loading plates, written instructions, and questionnaires on trays in this commercial-style kitchen. But this is not like any other restaurant kitchen. The staff members not only prepare the food; they carefully weigh, measure, and record the food before it's served. They also weigh and measure what diners leave on their plates.
The adjoining dining room is also not
typical. There are 16 individual cubicles separated by short walls and long,
blue curtains, rather like the instant-photo booths once found in variety
stores. Buffet tables are set up where dishes are kept hot. Small, unobtrusive
video cameras record food selections at the buffet and the eating habits of
diners inside the booths, all of it broadcast to monitors in the kitchen and in
some of the offices surrounding the dining room.
Welcome to Pennsylvania State University's Laboratory for the Study of Human
Ingestive Behavior, one of the world's most sophisticated centers for the study
of what and how humans eat. The queen of this quirky culinary empire is Barbara
Rolls, professor and Guthrie chair in nutrition at the university. For nearly
three decades, Rolls, 60, has researched food choices, portion sizes, the
caloric or energy density of foods, and myriad other factors that influence the
human appetite and what satisfies it.
Most recently, the lab has been studying the impact of energy or calorie
density--that is, the number of calories in a given weight of food--on satiety
and weight control. Rolls calls this research "Volumetrics," and her new book,
The Volumetrics Eating Plan, arrives in bookstores this week. Part
weight-control program, part cookbook, it is an effort to put into practical
form a lifetime of study on why people eat what they do and how to satisfy the
human biological drive for abundant food while achieving a healthy weight.
It was Rolls who realized that satiety, or the sensation of fullness, is "food
specific." That is, when people are full of one food, they can still eat
another--an explanation, says Rolls, "for why you always have room for dessert."
She was among the first to notice that humans eat about the same weight or
volume of food every day but not the same calories, a notion now accepted by
nutrition scientists.
Supersize. Yet she also discovered an apparent contradiction: When food portions
are "supersized," people eat more. Adults offered four different portions of
macaroni and cheese at her lab ate 30 percent more calories when given the
largest portion, compared with the smallest. Fewer than half noticed any
difference in the serving sizes. Likewise, in Rolls's sandwich experiments, men
and women were served 6-, 8-, 10-, and 12-inch submarine sandwiches. When given
the 12-inch sub, women ate 31 percent more calories and men 56 percent
more--compared with those given the 6-inch sub. Asked to rate their fullness
after lunch, diners reported little difference whether they had eaten the larger
or smaller sub. In a two-day study, portion sizes were increased for some dishes
by as much as 100 percent, and people continued to eat more over both days. "As
to why people respond this way, I don't know, but that is part of what we're
working on," Rolls says. "Clearly, visual and cognitive cues are important."
more